Case 39 (2009)
Case 39 didn't go anywhere new but I really enjoyed the ride. I'll have to watch out for Christian Alvart as a director - Pandorum (2009) also had a great atmosphere, although in that case the script was an unsalvageable mess. Case 39 involves a young girl who might be the innocent victim of abuse or might be pure evil. I'll give you one guess...
What To Watch Next
If you enjoyed Case 39 then the Full On Fear horror movie recommendation engine suggests that you might like to try these: