Forget Me Not (2009)
Over the days that follow the young people see the stranger again, individually. And when they do... they die.
At this stage there are a dozen standard slasher plots to choose from. However it becomes clear that this is something different when we realise that with the exception of Sandy (Carly Schroeder) nobody else remembers the dead person and he or she effectively never existed. Now it's getting interesting.
Interesting but not complicated, we're given a good idea what's going on very early through a series of flashbacks. However the extra element is enough to raise this above the standard slasher fare and there are a couple of plot elements not revealed until late in the film.
Of course the kids do get killed off in various interesting ways and there's the usual "guess who's next" game. But the supernatural element makes whole thing a lot more engaging than just having some motiveless psycho-killer on the loose.
The film is decently made. There's some annoying shaky camerawork but it's not extreme enough to make the film unwatchable. The characters are authentically unpleasant. The script works, given that it's not supposed to be a mystery, and has some very good lines plus a great ending.
It would have been easy for me to give up on this film after the first ten minutes, I'm glad I didn't. Forget Me Not is an interesting twist on the genre which gets better as it goes on.
What To Watch Next
If you enjoyed Forget Me Not then the Full On Fear horror movie recommendation engine suggests that you might like to try these: